![]() |
Back to Dogs Forum Forums Home Members Area
Dogs Forum
| Pages 1 2 Next |
| Member | Message | ||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Bad Decision?
So we want to get a great Pyrenese puppy. The thing is, we know Rikka won’t accept another dog. She’d rip it to pieces. So we were thinking that when Rikka has her puppies, maybe we’ll introduce her to a little great Pyrenese puppy. I figure maybe her maternal instincts will make her less aggressive towards it. But I’m wary of doing it because I’m afraid she’ll feel threatened and just be even more protective over her litter. Is there a way, or should we just settle with the dogs we have? |
||
| 12/18/09 07:38pm |
|
||
|
RubberDuckey273 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106166 Bad Decision?
if you wait, you might find that you fall in love with one of Rikka’s pups. that would be much better than getting another puppy, since Rikka’s puppies are going to need homes anyway. if you decide not to keep one of her puppies, you can always consider getting your GP puppy later. and, its going to be crazy enough as it is for you to have Rikka’s little ones running around without worrying about another puppy as well. |
||
| 12/18/09 09:31pm |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106190 Bad Decision?
I wanted to get the puppy when she had her litter, because I thought she might be less aggressive towards puppies when she had puppies of her own. I know that she’ll never accept another dog, and it’s too dangerous to try. She would shred a puppy to pieces the moment it came near her family. And if we got a full grown GP, I’m afraid there would be a dog fight, between really big dogs. I still do want one of Rikka’s sons, but I’m afraid of what a mix breed would do to the livestock when he got older. |
||
| 12/19/09 12:21am |
|
||
|
RubberDuckey273 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106217 Bad Decision?
the problem with introducing a puppy to a new mother is that their hormones make them even more unpredictable than normal. i honestly think you’d have a better chance introducing a new puppy to Rikka after her puppies have gone off to their new homes rather than while she still has them. you could always try to have a test done to find out what kind of mix the puppies are once they’re born and go from there. look into dog DNA testing, dog breed testing, etc. they obviously cant test for every know breed, but they do test for the most common. it sounds like a Great Pyrenees would be an excellent choice though. you say that Rikka will tear the puppy up; what has happened as far as dog aggression with her? most dogs will eventually get used to new dogs, and if you wait until after Rikka’s pups are gone, she might be more receptive to "adopting" a new puppy since she’ll probably be missing her babies. one of our customers had a tibetan mastiff that was very dog aggressive, and we had to be extremely careful how close we walked him to other dogs, because he could be so dangerous. but the owner decided to get another dog (a cocker mix) and they slowly introduced the puppy to him until he was used to her. once he got used to her, she became his little sister. as long as you go about introducing Rikka to a new puppy slowly, carefully and calmly, she should eventually accept it. however, if you go that route, make sure that whoever you get the puppy from will take the puppy back in the event that Rikka wont accept it, and will at least give you a partial refund. |
||
| 12/19/09 02:33am |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106230 Bad Decision?
We’ll have to see about the GP. We couldn’t get it by the time she has her litter anyways. She’s farther along than we thought. |
||
| 12/19/09 02:41am |
|
||
|
RubberDuckey273 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106232 Bad Decision?
if Rikka responds well to treats, you could reward her when she shows good behavior around the puppy, and lots of praise. if she growls, tell her no, then remove the puppy from the room and stop giving her treats. ignore her for a few minutes. then, bring the puppy back in the room and give Rikka lots of praise and start giving her treats again. keep doing that, for maybe 15 minutes at a time. you want Rikka to associate the puppy with praise and treats. there’s a lot of stuff you can do to help Rikka get used to a new member of the family, but you have time to figure out what you want to do. |
||
| 12/19/09 02:57am |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106235 Bad Decision?
She responds well to treats sometimes. The only treat that will motivate her is seaweed. Is that okay to give her? I gave her some as a joke once. You know, Akitas are a Japanese breed and people eat a lot of seaweed in Japan, so I gave her a little and she went crazy for it. Can I use that? |
||
| 12/19/09 03:03am |
|
||
|
RubberDuckey273 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106236 Bad Decision?
i know what you mean. my boss’s akita is protective of not only her and her husband, but me and my coworker who are like her extended family. there’s a reason they used them as babysitters for the royal children =) |
||
| 12/19/09 03:41am |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106240 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/19/09 12:52pm |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106240 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/19/09 12:56pm |
|
||
|
Saucier View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106297 Bad Decision?
And with regards to Rikka I think you may have a problem, to me it sounds like she thinks she is pack leader. Also with the gp they are not push overs once that pup(if you do decide to get it)is old enough it will have no problem defending itself against a Rikka, considering they get quite a bit larger and are bred to be bold enough and strong to chase away wolves and bears, the gp could do serious damage to an Akita. Just wanted to point somethings out!!!!goodluck either way |
||
| 12/19/09 01:20pm |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106297 Bad Decision?
I’m not saying mutts are bad dogs. I have a mutt, and she’s a really good dog. What I mean is that you don’t know the breeds, and different breeds tend to have different temperaments. I will stay firm to the belief that I can’t trust mutts around my livestock(besdies Ayla, my mutt) because I don’t know what breeds they have in them, and some breeds are more likely to kill livestock than others. Personally, I prefer purebred dogs. But I have nothing against mutts, because I love my mutt to death. ANY dog can be a livestock killer. Not just mutts. Out of the three dogs I had, two turned out to be trustworthy and one didn’t. My point is, I don’t know if I’m willing to bring in another dog that might kill my livestock. A GP wouldn’t They’re bred to guard livestock. Mutts aren’t. By the way, I’m not judging mutts because of what one did. I have a mutt that I trust 100% around my livestock. I was saying that I didn’t trust another dog that might kill my livestock. And yes, I do think that mutts are more likely, because you have no idea what breeds they are, and that makes a big impact on it. |
||
| 12/19/09 01:24pm |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106307 Bad Decision?
It is in the way you raise the dog, you will have that puppy from birth, which means you can expose it to the live stock at a young age, teach it that live stock is part of your pack and not food. Raising a puppy from birth will benifit you in several ways. I would not bring an unfamiliar dog into the pack if you Akita is the way she is with other dogs, because trust me, an overly dominat female will kill another animal, even a dog if she feels it is a threat to her pack. Thats why it would be wiser to keep one of the puppies. If your so untrusting of mixed breed canines then maybe you shouldn’t have made it possible for your purebred dog to bred with another dog not of her breed. Your not to blame for that, I know. There is no dog that has the predatorial insticts that you claim they have unless their hunting dogs. Akita, shepherds, malamutes, exc. All the dogs you listed that she might be mixed with, none have those instinct. You need to be a little bit more logical then your being and think about what is best for your other dogs, don’t say you want a pure bred because your scared a mixed breed will kill a goat, say you want a pure bred for the looks, because the other theory is rediculous. Any dog is capapble of killing, just think of what Rikka might do to that puppy you want to bring home. I’ve seen it happen with one of my rescues, do you really want that??? |
||
| 12/19/09 08:59pm |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106411 Bad Decision?
If you didn’t notice, I was very upset when I found out Rikka was pregnant. I didn’t want her to get pregnant. This was the first heat cycle I had, as well as my mom, and she didn’t understand. Rikka got away. Everyone makes mistakes. I did not come here asking for help to be criticized. I DO NOT prefer purebred dogs because they won’t kill livestock, as I’m QUITE aware that they can and will, depending on the dog. I prefer purebred dogs, because that is what I prefer. It’s called an opinion. As for akitas not having the hunting instinct, I must disagree. Since they were once bred to hunt large game such as deer. But, she’s never hurt any of my livestock, so I trust her just fine. I’m not here to argue. So I won’t. I’m sorry if I prefer purebreds over mutts. I wasn’t aware I wasn’t allowed an opinion on this forum. Every dog is different. And obviously I wouldn’t let that happen to the GP. I may have made a mistake with Rikka, but I’m not irresponsible. Thanks to everyone who gave me actual suggestions. I can’t say the same for the criticism of my personal opinion. I won’t get the GP for obvious reasons. I would like to keep a puppy, always have. Just trying to respect my mom’s wishes. If she doesn’t allow it, she doesn’t allow it. But hey. Maybe for Christmas she’ll let me. |
||
| 12/19/09 09:28pm |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106418 Bad Decision?
I prefer purebred dogs over mixed breeds, I love mixed breeds, but I like purebreds because they were bred for a specific reason. They have a purpose. I do believe in mixed breeding dogs to improve and inhance s=certain traits, but not because you think the puppies will be cute. I believe I said that her getting pregnant wasn’t your fault, as a matter of fact Quote: Your not to blame for that, I know. I quoted it.
Pardon me if I find it rediculous that you or your mother doesn’t want to keep one of the pups for stupid reasons. Maybe if your mother knew the facts, she wouldn’t feel that way. But either way, whether you keep one or not. I wouldn’t be bringing a new dog into Rikka’s territory/pack. It wouldn’t be a very wise decision and hopefully you can see that. I am going to college to be a vet tech, I’ve learned about these things. I have had several rescues and dogs of my own. Hell, I have a rottweiler that is the most gentle animal outside of the house but is very over protective in the house. The honest thing to do would be to give Rikka as little stress as possible, not getting a new dog would be best. Your going to have problems with her and the other dog...I wouldn’t make the situation anymore stressful for her, then it already is. If you still think I’m judging you rather then looking out for the dogs best interest then i’m sorry. i have learned through experiance and training what to do and what not to do, If you would rather take opinion over fact then thats up to you...... |
||
| 12/19/09 11:53pm |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106454 Bad Decision?
Look, I had a traumatizing time with Erin, and I worked my hardest to teach her not to attack the livestock. But after an injured baby goat, a dead baby goat, an injured sheep, and a dead sheep, I’m starting to question that it’s all in the way they’re brought up. I didn’t say it wasn’t true, but I didn’t say it was. I have doubts, but I do believe that you can raise them not to. I just couldn’t do it with Erin. I’m sorry, I must have missed that sentence. And I DO want to keep a puppy, because I know I would work harder to train him not to do what Erin did. My mom doesn’t understand dogs much. I’m going my best to get her to understand their mentality. She also has her dog-hating boyfriend to convince her she shouldn’t keep one. I’m trying my best. I’m perfectly willing to except that answer. The reason I came asking this question was to see if it was a bad idea. I don’t know nearly as much as a vet tech like yourself, so I thought I’d ask. I have to say, I’ve never owned an aggressive dog. All the dogs that my family has owned have been cocker and CKC spaniels. Not aggressive in the least, so I wasn’t quite sure. I did feel a little bit judged. But I also see that you’re trying to look out for my dogs. And I respect that. I’m not trying to argue. I just got defensive. I won’t get the GP. You’re right about what you’re saying, and I see that. |
||
| 12/20/09 10:48am |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106504 Bad Decision?
She is an animal lover, not like me, but we as woman have a choice and we have the right to use it. |
||
| 12/20/09 10:56am |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106509 Bad Decision?
In the beginning, when we first found out she was pregnant, I asked her to keep a puppy, and she said I could, and we agreed I could keep a male. But then her boyfriend intervened and brought up all this crap about why we shouldn’t keep one. He doesn’t even has a job. He lives here full time, sleeps till noon, and then plays on his computer all day. he doesn’t pay bills or even support our farm, but somehow he still gets to decide whether I get to keep my dog’s son. |
||
| 12/20/09 11:08am |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2106512 Bad Decision?
Just keep reading and asking the vet questions, if you need to know something you can’t find, call the vet. If you can’t get it from him pm me, I can give you my email or cell number. I really love how people claim to know everything about dogs just because someone they know had dogs or fostered dogs. If they haven’t physically worked hands on with them and recieved an education on them they don’t really know everything. I’ve done both and I still don’t know absolutly everything there is to know. All you can do and work your hardest to make sure her and those puppies are healthy and happy, and for now, thats all that matters. Thats what seperates a good dog owner from a bad dog owner. It is good to give the mother her time alone with the pups, so that she can bond with them and nurse them, but it is also important for her human to bond with the pups and help her with them. That will make a more human socialized, more affectinate puppy. Because of you socializing with them from day 1, exposing them to their surrounds (live stock), and giving them extra attention. That will make them good dogs in the future. It gives them a good start, showing them the live stock and bring them around it when they are young will teach them to ignore it, it’s just a natural surrounding. The reason you had trouble with the other dog is probably because you didn’t begin bringing her around it as young as possible, letting her watch the other dogs around the livestock to learn that it wasn’t prey. It takes time to make good puppies, you have that time. Use it wisely. |
||
| 12/20/09 11:24am |
|
||
|
RubberDuckey273 View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2106514 Bad Decision?
for example: my dog is a breed that was bred mainly for hunting. despite the fact that she was raised with ferrets and cats, she has on numerous occasions tried to kill rats, hamsters, birds, stray cats, and even the ferrets she was raised with. i did tons of research on the breed before i got her, so luckily i knew that there was a chance that she wouldn’t tolerate small animals. now imagine if i hadn’t known about that trait. if i hadn’t, there’s a very good chance that the last time i went to visit my mom (who has the ferrets) i would have just let Signey loose with the ferrets, and she would have torn them to pieces before i could have stopped her. yes, for right now it is important for you to focus on raising the puppies. i’m sure you will figure out what works for you, and in all likelyhood, if you keep one of Rikka’s puppies and raise it with the livestock it’ll be just fine. but your caution and bias is not unjustified. its always better to be safe than sorry when it comes to the lives of any living creature. |
||
| 12/20/09 09:02pm |
|
||
|
HerpsinIN View Profile |
Message To: RubberDuckey273 In reference to Message Id: 2106664 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/21/09 08:05pm |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: HerpsinIN In reference to Message Id: 2107035 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/21/09 08:07pm |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2107036 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/21/09 10:02pm |
|
||
|
HerpsinIN View Profile |
Message To: LizaB2008 In reference to Message Id: 2107083 Bad Decision?
I have been reading these posts on this forum, and I am shocked how irresponsible/uneducated people are on here! To the OP- WHy the heck are you wanting or even considered breeding your aggressive akita? You call it protection aggression, I call it irresponsible ownership who doesnt know how to handle their dog! These types of posts are the reason I do not visit this forum very much. They just upset me with the ignorance of the members! |
||
| 12/22/09 09:01am |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: HerpsinIN In reference to Message Id: 2107182 Bad Decision?
|
||
| 12/22/09 09:05am |
|
||
|
Ammeratsu View Profile |
Message To: Ammeratsu In reference to Message Id: 2107184 Bad Decision?
What do you mean, "why am I considering breeding my aggressive akita? Akita’s are "aggressive"(protective) by nature! It’s in every description of akitas you’ll find. If I had a dog that wasn’t protective at all, I wouldn’t consider breeding that one, because that’s not how the breed was bred to be. I consider breeding Rikka because she is an excellent and healthy example of her breed, temperament and appearance. You call it irresponsible of me because my dog as the typical temperament for her breed. Oh, excuse me for having a good quality animal. |
||
| 12/22/09 09:18am |
|
||
|
Ghastly View Profile |
Message To: HerpsinIN In reference to Message Id: 2107182 Bad Decision?
Quote: the OP- WHy the heck are you wanting or even considered breeding your aggressive akita?
first off you state that you look through the forum perhaps if you looked through it with the clouds cleared from your eyes you would have seen a topic to which inside it stated that Rikka got away. You may see that as her fault or you may not if you do well thats tough hamster brain accidents happen when owning dogs heck i know that and im sure you do too and im sure you have mad a fair few mistakes in your time no matter if it was a dog, cat, small animal or reptile, accidents happen bloody deal with it! Quote: I have been reading these posts on this forum, and I am shocked how irresponsible/uneducated people are on here
uneducated?! Some if not mist of us are educated in training or vet nursing and some are training to become one hich is part of these jobs and we learn from eachother. I myself train dogs - i have two Bullmastiffs i trained for hunting and i purchase Dobermann from breeders and train them in Schutzhund most are working in Europe as thats where i stay i have a handful of them that work in USA all are trained to be army and police dogs - protection, bomb detection and drug detection, all you know one or two of my dogs may be in your town! I also have a bachelor degree in vet nursing so shove that up your backside!! So what do you have to show?! Quote: These types of posts are the reason I do not visit this forum very much. They just upset me with the ignorance of the members!
well im sure my posting is just the cherr on the icing! I think you will find that us here on the dog forum are close and always stand by eachother so obviously a stranger coming along backhanding is going to set one of us off! Plus if you dont like it on here that much but despite its a free country sometimes silence is the smartest remark and if you dont like me or anyone else hey the feelings proberly mutual! Merry xmas :) |
||
| 12/22/09 09:21am |
|
||
|
FutureVet123 View Profile |
Message To: Ghastly In reference to Message Id: 2107188
I think it would be a good idea to nip this in the bud before anything becomes out of control and say that bottom line, everyone on here just wants to do what’s best for their pet. -Peaches and Jeni |
||
| 12/22/09 10:08am |
|
||
|
LizaB2008 View Profile |
Message To: FutureVet123 In reference to Message Id: 2107212 Bad Decision?
You have been reading all of the post and we’re all so irresponsible and uneducated. Her is a little information for your uneducated self. I am going to school for vetrinary technology/technician and have rescuing dog and birds since I was young and even now as an adult still do it. I know everything there is to know about comunicable disease and viruses. I have also whelped puppies of my own from both rescue dogs and responsible breedings, as a matter of fact I artificially inseminated a Great Dane. I have my rescues and my own dogs spayed/neutered ASAP. I am educated and highly responsible. As are mostly everyone else on here, this fifteen year old girl has done all of her research and got everything prepared for her dog to give birth, not something most kids her age would have the responsibility to do, most would leave it to their parents. I thing she deserves a good job for that. Not being critisized. I congratulate her for doing what she did even though it was just her responsibilty. It was an accident that her dog got pregnant, and I sure if she did plan breed the dog she would have been just as responsible. To be honest, we don’t really give a flying pig if you don’t come to this forum ever again. As a matter of fact how about you go do some growing up and then come back! |
||
| 12/22/09 10:42am |
|
||
|
Ghastly View Profile |
Message To: FutureVet123 In reference to Message Id: 2107212 Bad Decision?
ey know best towards our dog section "family" :) Quote: I think it would be a good idea to nip this in the bud before anything becomes out of control and say that bottom line, everyone on here just wants to do what’s best for their pet.
ill go sit in a corner with a muzzle on because i can see me being the insinuator haha :) |
||
| 12/22/09 10:42am |
|
| Pages 1 2 Next |