Your Reptile and Amphibian Resource and Information Site

Back to Frogs Forum   Forums   Home   Members Area  

Frogs Forum

ILoveGreen   Keechoo   Keechoo   ILoveGreen   Keechoo   Keechoo   Herpboywonder   ILoveGreen   ILoveGreen   Keechoo  
 Member  Message

 #1397981


ILoveGreen
View Profile





 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

Sometimes, when people set up a terrarium they wish to create a "mini ecosystem" and add a mix of species that will cohabitate in the terrarium. While in theory this sounds like a good idea, it is a situation fraught with difficulties and can only be achieved with a great deal of research and work. For the average keeper of reptiles and amphibians, it is not something I would recommend. Here is why:
Different species have different requirements, even if the differences seem quite minor especially for species from similar climates. However, in the wild each species occupies a unique niche even within the same general climate, where temperature, light, humidity vary depending on the specific habitat of each species (e.g. tree vs ground dwelling, terrestrial vs. aquatic). In an unnatural situation (the terrarium), it is hard to provide an environment that closely duplicates the natural environment needed to keep single species healthy and stress-free. Providing natural conditions for multiple species is extrememly complicated.
Terrariums for mixed species generally need to be much larger than those for a single species, and are more difficult to maintain. Extra room is needed to provide the proper environmental conditions and furnishings for each species, as well as allowing each species their own space to hunt and interact somewhat naturally. Crowding different species together in a small tank can be a recipe for disaster.
Carnivorous critters are usually not picky eaters, and will try to eat smaller cagemates of any species. This applies to animals (lizards, frogs, salamanders) that are largely insectivorous; most of these will not hesitate to hunt other small critters given the opportunity especially if confined in a tank with them. Also consider the stress you place on an animal, confining it in close quarters with a potential predator.
Toxicity may be an issue with some frogs, salamanders, and newts. Many secrete mild skin toxins. These toxins may not be dangerous to humans, but they can accumulate in a tank and cause problems if absorbed through the skin of other tank inhabitants or if a cagemate tries to eat a toxic amphibian.
Animals may become stressed by behaviors and displays that are unexpected and that they do no know how to intrpret. Between species that do not normally coexist, normal behaviors and benign displays may be misinterpreted, and this may lead to fighting or stress.
Animals from different areas or habitats have differing immunities to parasites and infectious diseases. Therefore, one species may harbour a bug that it can carry with no ill-effects. However, if that bug (be it a parasite, virus or bacteria) is introduced to a species with no natural immunity, the result can be devastating.
I know there are people out there that have mixed tanks that seem to do just fine, but my recommendation is to stick to one species per tank. The results of mixing species of reptile and amphibian in a terrarium are unpredictable, especially for less experienced keepers. Providing the proper environment and alleviating stress are too important to the health and well-being of reptiles and amphibians to take chances with mixing species.

If i have missed anything please add to it.
i HOPE this answers everyones questions about mixing of species!!!!!

Natasha reposted by me...Lisa :)



08/10/07  06:25pm

 #1424736


Keechoo
View Profile



  Message To: ILoveGreen   In reference to Message Id: 1397981


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

bump



08/29/07  08:06pm

 #1426828


Keechoo
View Profile



  Message To: Keechoo   In reference to Message Id: 1424736


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

bump



08/31/07  10:24am

 #1434401


ILoveGreen
View Profile



  Message To: Keechoo   In reference to Message Id: 1426828


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

hop



09/06/07  10:06pm

 #1450507


Keechoo
View Profile



  Message To: ILoveGreen   In reference to Message Id: 1434401


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

Hippity hop



09/20/07  01:27pm

 #1459228


Keechoo
View Profile



  Message To: Keechoo   In reference to Message Id: 1450507


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

bumping



09/27/07  01:14pm

 #1459429


Herpboywonder
View Profile



  Message To: Keechoo   In reference to Message Id: 1459228


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

This is a very general argument. Many species coexist together even in the same niche. For example, in Florida there may be 20 species of gecko living on one wall. In many habitats animals are capable of living together in harmony. The tank must be large however to mix species. Mixing nocturnal and diurnal species also reduces the amount of time that they see each other.



09/27/07  04:34pm

 #1459477


ILoveGreen
View Profile



  Message To: Herpboywonder   In reference to Message Id: 1459429


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

The thing is that with the geckos on the wall...they are just basking and are able to run endlessly to get away from the others when need be. They wouldn’t have that option even in a 150 gallon...I have one and it’s really not too big. :)



09/27/07  05:08pm

 #1522240


ILoveGreen
View Profile



  Message To: ILoveGreen   In reference to Message Id: 1459477


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

bump!



11/21/07  04:59pm

 #1683347


Keechoo
View Profile



  Message To: ILoveGreen   In reference to Message Id: 1522240


 MIXING DIFFERENT SPECIES! why not to!

Bumping again



03/31/08  10:13am


Back to Frogs Forum   Forums   Home   Members Area